To Beringer or Not to Beringer: That Is the Question

General purpose discussions.
Post Reply
User avatar
stathis
Posts: 10
Joined: Fri Oct 04, 2024 3:56 pm
Location: Seattle, WA, USA

To Beringer or Not to Beringer: That Is the Question

Post by stathis »

Hello and Happy New Year,

I know there’s an older threads discussing Beringer wheelset/brakes and the complexities of installing them, but now that they’re offered as a standard option for the TSi and HW models, I assume the installation process is streamlined and well-documented.

There seems to be a lot of excitement around Beringer. They’re highlighted on Sling’s website, and I’ve seen numerous references to them in Sling’s YouTube videos. As I consider this option for my TSi build, I’ve been trying to weigh the pros and cons of choosing Beringer over the stock Matcos. After doing some research and reading through the specs, here’s my high-level understanding of the trade-offs:

Pros of Beringer:
  • Superior Braking Performance & Anti-Skid Functionality: Beringer systems provide more balanced braking, improving directional control during landing and taxiing, which can be a significant advantage in certain conditions.
  • Reduced Weight: While Beringer brakes/wheel are lighter than stock configuration, the difference is only a few pounds, so weight savings may not be a major consideration for most pilots.
  • Durability & Longevity: Made with aircraft-grade aluminum, stainless steel, and advanced composites, Beringer offer exceptional durability and resistance to corrosion. They’re designed to reduce maintenance frequency and long-term costs, with fewer parts that wear out over time compared to traditional braking systems.
  • Sleek Design & Cool Engineering: Beringer are visually appealing, often anodized in colors like red or black. They add a high-performance aesthetic to the aircraft, which could be attractive to those who appreciate well-engineered components.
Cons of Beringer:
  • Cost: The initial cost is high—my last quote was around $8,000. While Beringer brakes require less frequent maintenance, the maintenance costs are higher compared to Matcos, which could be a significant consideration for some.
  • Accessibility & Availability: Unlike more common systems (like Matcos), finding parts or qualified A&Ps to service Beringer brakes could be more challenging, especially in remote locations. This might lead to delays or difficulties if you’re stranded somewhere.
Key Considerations:

While I’m still evaluating my options, here are the factors I’ve been thinking about:
  • Economics: It’s possible that Beringer brakes may offer a better total cost of ownership (TCO) over time, but it’s unclear when that crossover point occurs. I imagine it would take several years before the increased initial cost is offset by lower maintenance costs.
  • Safety: Beringer brakes certainly offer enhanced performance, which could improve safety. However, from my research, it seems that brake failures are rarely a major factor in general aviation accidents. In the few cases I found, lack of maintenance seemed to be the main cause.
  • Mission Efficacy: My primary mission is cross-country flying. I’m not sure how much the performance benefits of Beringer brakes will improve this mission. Better reliability is a plus, but the potential difficulty in accessing parts and finding familiar A&Ps may be a downside for long-distance travel.
  • Cool Engineering: As an engineer, I love well-designed and manufactured components. This is partly why I chose Sling—it’s a modern aircraft with high-tech components like the Rotax engine and Garmin avionics. Beringer aligns well with this philosophy. However, since we’re using wheel covers, the visual appeal of the brakes might be less relevant to me.
While Beringer seem like a good option, I’m unsure whether the benefits justify the cost and potential downsides for my use case, which is pretty typical. I suspect that I might be missing something.

I’m curious to hear your thoughts. Why are you excited about Beringer wheelset/brakes ?

Looking forward to your feedback!

Stathis
User avatar
lutorm
Posts: 97
Joined: Fri Jan 28, 2022 11:00 pm
Location: Sweden

Re: To Beringer or Not to Beringer: That Is the Question

Post by lutorm »

I remember Evan making a video about upgrading to a larger Matco brake, because he thought the standard ones were too small. I guess Sling agreed since they upgraded the standard option. I personally think the move to Beringer is a way to position themselves as a "premium" product. I really have no direct experience with either but I don't hear people constantly complaining about the old brakes so I'm going to go with the ones I got in my kit. If it turns out that I'm unhappy with them, I can upgrade.

As for cost, I really doubt you'd "make back" the higher cost in lower maintenance. I think you should just think of it as a higher performance product, for which some people might be willing to pay a premium and some people won't think it's worth it. I guess if you know you're going to be going into short fields that will require max braking then it might make sense. (But on such a short runway, will you be able to take off?)
Blog of various projects: https://blog.familjenjonsson.org/blog/
Montreal
Posts: 10
Joined: Tue Apr 04, 2023 2:09 pm
Location: Houston, TX KSGR

Re: To Beringer or Not to Beringer: That Is the Question

Post by Montreal »

I think you are spot on with your pro-con list. IMO Beringer is a marginal improvement on performance and it looks cool which translates to increased value. I have installed Beringer product on a Cessna and the owner did report improved braking/stopping distance compared to Cleveland brakes (look similar to Matco design) and shaved ~4lbs off empty weight. Beringer customer service is responsive and prompt and they have excellent reference manuals and videos on how to maintain/assemble. On the mx end of things, also consider you will have to jack the aircraft main gear to change the brake pads because the wheel needs to be removed from Beringer axle
STGove
Posts: 36
Joined: Thu Dec 08, 2022 9:08 am
Location: League City, TX
Contact:

Re: To Beringer or Not to Beringer: That Is the Question

Post by STGove »

Since your brining up the need to jack up the plane, I thought about sharing this:

https://www.aircraftspruce.com/catalog/ ... -05118.php

https://www.aircraftspruce.com/catalog/ ... -12379.php


Has anyone put these into our wings?
Respectfully,
Steve & Emily Gove
First time Sling TSi Builders - League City, Tx
N720S (Reserved)
YouTube.com/@N720S
HAM W1WHO
Cell: 713.818.5800
eMail: SteveEmilyGove@gmail.com
Venit inferni, sive in excelsum aqua - TEXAS Strong!
Post Reply